The world would be a better place without accountants
I suspect you will disagree with my statement arguing that your CEO isn’t a former accountant or that your CTO didn’t even take a single accounting class in his life and I would agree with you. Not all accountants carry a pocket size calculator.
I personally don’t have many complaints about accounting itself, after all there is value in knowing how much money enters your coffers and how much you had to spend to generate the associated revenue. That makes perfect sense to me. Where I have a problem is when common sense leaves the building to make place for accountant-based logic and the need to book everything against the right account and the use of money within certain time intervals.
Confused? Let me explain.
Let’s take project management [Ah, now you are starting to see a link between accountants and Agile projects]. In many of the organizations I had the pleasure to work with, compliance to project plans was more important than delivering real value to customers. Nobody asked if it made sense to add new features or change the sequence of activities in an attempt to deliver business value to customers faster. People are concerned with compliance to the plan. And where does this need for compliance come from you ask? Accountants.
Before the debit-credit masters come running after me with their red pen, I will confess I used to be one of them (sorry!). I understand the mindset, their perspective of the world and most of all, the need to put things in neatly defined categories – some can be amortized while others can’t – but I digress.
The project timelines are derived from the accounting cycles – the money is allocated for a certain budgeting period instead of true market needs. The phasing and allocation of the resources is driven by the departmental allocated budgets. The profile of the resources assigned to a project is driven by who has the money as opposed to who has the skill set.
Does any of this make sense in a context of business excellence? That’s one of the reasons why I like Scrum with its focus on delivering the highest business value sooner. Scrum isn’t perfect, I know but it forces people to make decision based on business value, not accounting rules.
Scrum is also great a giving visibility the what is really going on within a project as opposed to estimated project completion for cost computation. In heuristic tasks such as software development is it really critical to know that task ABC costed $357? Chances are, you are unlikely to do anything useful with that information. Why wouldn’t you rather determine the cost of an iteration (or a sprint) so you can compare it to the business value delivered. As I stated earlier, there is value in accounting but when everybody starts to behave like an accountant, it is a sure sign that common sense is gone and that the organization is ripe for an Agile makeover.